Sunday, May 18, 2008

Chinese Quake A Wake-Up Call For California

Written on M.S. Prinsendam, in Western Mediterranean Sea--

The earthquake in China's Sichuan province was measured at magnitude 7.9, and some measures of the San Francisco quake of 1906 were that it was magnitude 7.8. Others put it at 8.1 or 8.3.

Regardless which San Francisco figure is correct, the earthquake's power in China is roughly about the same, and that in itself should give us in California cause for reflection. In 1995, at the time of the Kobe quake in Japan, Shelby Coffey, then editor of the L.A. Times, sent me to Japan to do stories on what bearing the quake there had on California quake issues, and I think those stories were quite useful. This time, from what I can read on the L.A. Times Web site, the newspaper, which has grown smaller, has relied on its Asian correspondents to provide all the China quake coverage, and they went in without much quake expertise.

The fact is, a quake the size of the Sichuan earthquake is going to cause terrible damage and casualties in California, were a similar quake to occur there. The high rise buildings constructed since 1906 might well be vulnerable, if the temblor were centered anywhere close to one of the big cities. Also, today, there are all kinds of aqueducts, computer systems and modern highways that have proven in other locales to be susceptible to great damage by intense shaking. Scientific studies have indicated a major quake could occur within a few years in the San Francisco Bay Area or the Inland Empire, San Bernardino, Riverside or Palm Springs, although, of course, no one can be certain where it might strike.

The Sichuan earthquake occurred at a time of day when many children were in school, and there are horrific stories of the schools collapsing, burying hundreds of children, of whom few have been rescued.

In California, several of the great earthquakes that occurred in the 20th Century took place at times of the day when the schools were closed. This was true with the San Francisco quake, the 1933 Long Beach quake, the 1971 San Fernando quake, the 1994 Northridge quake and so forth. That was fortunate, because school casualties were minimized, but we cannot count on such propitious timing being the case in future big quakes.

After 1933, California adopted the Field Act, mandating quake-related construction codes that afforded considerable protection to the state's public schools, although higher education was left uncovered. Since then, there has been an effort to extend safeguards to hospitals and to the general building codes. Many hospitals, however, have won delays in implementing the new standards.

In 2004, the year I retired, I did a story that found that in many respects that in the 10 years since Northridge, California had fallen back on earthquake safety. Many experts told me that California had failed to really improve earthquake construction standards, according to the latest findings, with the exception of retrofitting bridges on the freeways. There was also much less devotion in both the Davis and Schwarzenegger Administration to quake safety, and the state's Seismic Safety Commission had suffered devastating budgetary cutbacks and from the governors' lack of support.

Unfortunately, my story was watered down considerably before it appeared in the newspaper. Chiefly responsible for that was David Lauter, who in my absence on a South American trip before the story actually appeared, took it on himself to weaken the story, without consulting me, which he could have by telephone or e-mail. When I returned and read the story, I was very distressed and wrote a strong protest letter to Lauter and other, higher, editors.

There was never a meaningful response to my complaint. And when I retired, and science writer Lee Hotz subsequently left the newspaper for the Wall Street Journal, the coverage that had won the Times a Pulitzer Prize for Northridge coverage was allowed to languish. There is no one at the paper today who has the concern, or I daresay the knowledge, that we had on earthquake coverage.

I bring all this up now to urge in the strongest terms I can muster that the Times revive its interest in California quake protections. Sharon Bernstein and Hector Becerra have both done some good work in this area, and Shelby Grad has quite a bit of interest in it. But more detailed, tougher coverage is needed. (Another writer who contributed valuable stories on the Northridge quake, Doug Smith, also would be a great earthquake reporter).

We don't want to wake up some day to a major earthquake and find that as a result of not being ready, the quake had caused much greater loss of life and property damage than might have been the case had more protections been approved and implemented.

Incidentally, the Washington Post has an excellent story today about how the Chinese press has been covering the Sichuan quake with much more openness than was in evidence in China in the past.

Labels:

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

LAT Earthquake Insurance Reporting Falls Short

California's insurance coverage for earthquakes is even more inadequate than New Orleans' levees were in protecting that unfortunate city against a hurricane disaster.

The same kind of neglect is in evidence. Just as the Army Corps of Engineers and other agencies of the government failed totally to see that the levee system was extensive enough or strong enough to withstand even a hurricane like Katrina that glanced by New Orleans, so California' s Earthquake Authority is not only short of providing complete coverage: It provides coverage to only the small minority -- about 15% -- of California homeowners who buy it, and even for them the coverage is saddled with a high 15% deductible before it kicks in. This means that a $300,000 home would have to sustain $45,000 of covered damage, before the homeowner could collect anything. And much of what is understood generally as part of the property, such as garages and swimming pools, do not count toward satisfying the deductible at all. They are not covered.

Now, as L.A. Times reporter Marc Lifsher wrote in Tuesday's newspaper, the Legislature is preparing to reduce the required minimal support for the Earthquake Authority that the private insurance companies have hitherto had to give to satisfy claims, when they arise, by $1 billion from the initial $2.2 billion.

This move, another prospective giveaway by a corrupt Legislature and governor's office to a powerful private industry, would increase dramatically the chance that the Earthquake Authority's assets would be inadequate to pay even the small percentage of homeowners who carry the insurance, when a quake on the order of the San Francisco earthquake of 1906, or even the Northridge quake of 1994, occurs.

I say when, because ultimately another large earthquake is inevitable in California, and the state's ever-increasing density of population makes it ever more likely that the damages will be greater than they were in 1906 or 1994 (In Northridge, they were about $40 billion).

The reporter in this case has demonstrated before that he does not understand the numbers in the insurance business. Now, again he has failed to write an article which gives an accurate picture of the danger. His editors at the Times cannot escape responsibility either.

He does speculate, no doubt correctly, that fewer people will buy the insurance if the premiums go up. But he devotes no attention whatsoever to the question of how many homeowners, in a big quake, would be without any coverage, and he does not discuss the question then, of whether, the government would actually come to those people's rescue with its own funds.

We see in the Katrina disaster how government aid has been way short of providing enough to restore the New Orleans and Mississippi Gulf Coast areas to what they were before the 2005 hurricane. Just this week, the television networks have been recording that fact on the hurricane's second anniversary, and Time magazine did a major story. The unhappy truth is that the government, at least in the Bush Administration, has lost its will to provide adequate aid in such big disasters, and without substantial private insurance the relief is not going to come.

Yet in California, where the earthquake danger in the metropolitan areas may well exceed the hurricane danger along the Gulf Coast, state lawmakers allowed the insurance companies to ditch their responsibilities after they paid out $15 billion in Northridge claims and then bluffed the Legislature in 1996 into believing they would quit business in the state altogether unless they were relieved of most future liability to pay earthquake claims.

Originally, as Lifsher reports, the Earthquake Authority was projected to accumulate $6 billion in reserves and have 2 million insured homeowners by the end of 2008. It is falling well short of those goals, although, in this inadequate article, the author doesn't even say what reserve it has at present. He does report it has about 755,000 customers, one third the number projected by the end of next year.

There is nothing in this article about what scientists have said the odds of a big quake are in various areas of this state. Yet studies have been done on this matter, and the estimates are readily available. The odds on such a quake occurring in the next 30 years in both Northern and Southern California are high.

The Times, under Tribune Co. control, has let vital areas of coverage slip, but none more than in science, where the staff is just not anywhere near what it was. Still, it is necessary that the paper find someone who can cover the subject of insurance protection against damaging earthquakes far more satisfactorily than Lifsher has been doing.

I should not end this piece without saying a word about the death of David Garcia, a long time Southern California environmental reporter on television who was one of the few in the media who really was an earthquake expert and joined his knowledge with real interest. Garcia, who died in Palm Desert Tuesday of liver cancer at the age of 63, was the reporter for Channel 11, KTTV, during the Northridge quake, and performed impressively. He was an esteemed colleague and well liked by the earthquake scientists.

There have been no major damaging earthquakes in urban areas of California since 1994, and in their absence, public attention has drifted away from the danger. But it is there. Such earthquakes will occur, and we have to prepare for them. The Times, as the paper's largest newspaper, has a major responsibility to assist the public in this regard.

--

The Washington Post has an excellent story today on Japan's success developing Internet service much faster and more comprehensive than the U.S. The speed at obtaining information is, on the average, about 30 times higher in Japan than here. Also, in Japan, television seen on the Internet often matches in clarity that seen on ordinary television sets.

Labels:

Monday, June 18, 2007

L.A. Times Touts Junk In Quake Prediction Story

One of the great costs of the buyouts generated by the Tribune Co. at the Los Angeles Times is that institutional memory, another way of saying expertise, has been lost, and there was a powerful sign in Sunday's Opinion section over just how much has been lost. The Opinion pages used to have three Pulitzer Prize winners on staff before the former editorial page editor, Andres Martinez, who was finally forced out in a sex scandal himself, got rid of them all.

Perhaps if those prize winners were still on staff, the L.A. Times would not have printed as it did yesterday a spurious story indicating that five individuals, none of them active earthquake scientists, and, for all we are told, four of them not even scientists, had been able to predict major California earthquakes.

Two of the five examples cited were not earthquake predictions at all, and two others were dumb luck. Somebody having heart pains is simply not a guide to predicting earthquakes.

For a quake prediction to be valid, it has to state the time, place and magnitude of an earthquake and get all of these more or less right.

So for Marian Campbell to predict a 5.0 quake near the 40th parallel and then to have a 6.4 quake occur in the Gulf of California is not a prediction. Not only is a 6.4 nearly 40 times more powerful than a 5.0, but the earthquake that occurred was at least 800 miles away from where the prediction said a quake would be. The 40th parallel is near Eureka. The Gulf of California is nowhere close.

Not even as accurate was Jerry Hurley, who says he predicted a 5.0 or higher quake on June 14, 1995, off the California coast, and two days later, a 6.7 occurred. Not only would that quake be 70 times the size of a 5.0, but there was no such quake anywhere near off the California coast or anywhere in California on June 16, 1995. Hurley is making things up, and the Times should have checked him.

Similarly, Zhonghau Shou didn't actually make a "Bulls-eye prediction" when he said in August, 1999 that a major quake would hit east of L.A. A magnitude 7.1 quake did strike in the Mojave desert in October, 1999, but the "cloud patterns and shapes" that Shou said he used in making his prediction had no possible connection with an earthquake, and Shou simply had dumb luck in making the prediction. He probably knew that quakes as large as 7 occur in the Southern California desert every few years, and this one he predicted, but not through any causative knowledge.

The fact is, California has a lot of quakes, so every once in awhile, someone is going to be right with a prediction. But they haven't told us how often they were wrong about one.

Charlotte King says she felt severe heart pains in December, 1993 and predicted the 6.7 Northridge earthquake that occurred a month later. Baloney. Her heart pains had nothing to do with the earthquake.

Jim Berkland was closer to having a basis for predicting one, when, according to the Times, this "former geologist" predicted four days before, there would be a "world series quake," and then, the Loma Prieta quake occurred just before an Oakland A's-San Francisco Giants World Series game. Berkland apparently used observation of tides, lunar cycles and animal behavior to make the prediction. All these phenomena have sometimes been associated with earthquakes, but the links have not been scientifically confirmed.

The Times story, by Swati Pandey, says a "L.A. psychic," who is not identified, has predicted a 6.5 to 8.0 quake would hit Los Angeles by the end of the month.

We'll see. I'll pay $1,000 to a fund for drinks for Tribune Co. chairman Dennis FitzSimons, if there is such a quake.

The main thing is that the Times should never have run such a story, and would not have when I was reporting earthquakes in the years before I retired, without checking with real earthquake scientists to see whether they considered the five examples given to be real earthquake predictions.

If they had checked, they would have found the scientists saying the Times was being bullshitted, as it is all too frequently these days.

I'm having cantaloupe for breakfast this morning. That has nothing to do with future seismic behavior in California.

Labels: